When it comes to designing a fireplace for your home, there are many options to consider. However, before you decide on material selections for the mantel, hearth, and surround, you need to determine the type of fireplace you will install. The most common types of fireplaces are wood-burning, gas, and electric, and each comes with its own set of pros and cons. The choice of your fireplace model will affect aesthetics, energy costs, and the construction budget. So make sure you are informed before making your choice. To help, the architects at our Austin, Texas studio have put together a comparison guide outlining the pros and cons of wood-burning, gas, and electric fireplaces.

Nameless Road Residence, double sided Wood fireplace

Comparing Wood-burning Fireplaces

Wood-burning fireplaces offer old-world charm, character, and the enjoyment of ritual. In fact, wood-burning fireplaces are the most popular type of fireplace, and this in-demand feature can even increase a home’s resale value. However, that doesn’t mean it’s necessarily the best option for your home. Here are the pros and cons of wood-burning fireplaces.

The Advantages of a Wood-burning Fireplace

1. Aesthetics

Wood-burning fireplaces offer the enjoyment of a live flame and crackle of the fire. They promote a warm sense of gathering, and joy can be found snuggling next to the fire and merely watching its glow.

2. Resale Value

Wood-burning fireplaces can add up to $10,000 worth of resale value to your home. House hunters typically value the charm of a real wood-burning fireplace higher than other styles, giving your home a competitive edge in the market.

3. Alternative Heat Source

Unlike gas and electric fireplaces, wood-burning fireplaces have the added benefit of being off the grid. It can be beneficial in cold climates to have an alternative source of heat in case of power outages or gas line breaks.

The Disadvantages of a Wood-burning Fireplace

1. Expensive

Wood-burning fireplaces are the most costly to install, maintain, and operate. Since a chimney must be built into the home, it can be cost-prohibitive to add later on during a remodel. They also require expert craftsmanship and extra materials in a new construction build. Wood-burning fireplaces also need yearly maintenance and cleaning to ensure they are operating correctly, and they are not energy efficient.

2. Pollution

Many homeowners are reconsidering wood-burning fireplaces altogether because they release smoke and pollution outside and into the indoor air. While they offer nostalgic charm, they can be problematic for both the environment and your health.

3. Extra Work

Some people also don’t find the charm of chopping wood and kindling a fire to be very charming. The extra work and ritualistic nature of wood-burning fireplaces may not fit into your busy lifestyle when you want to relax at the end of a long day.

Comparing Gas Fireplaces

Gas fireplaces offer easy and convenient style at the flip of a switch as well as high energy efficiency to keep your home warm and cozy all winter. They are an excellent option for families who want extra charm without the work of a wood-burning fireplace. However, they do come with some drawbacks. Here are the pros and cons of gas fireplaces.

Bend of The River Residence, gas fireplace

The Advantages of a Gas Fireplace

1. Convenient Style

The biggest advantage of a gas fireplace is starting the roaring flame of a fire with just the flip of a switch. While it could take hours to collect wood and kindle a fire for a wood-burning model, it only takes seconds to start a gas fireplace. This simplicity makes it an excellent choice for families with busy lifestyles.

2. Energy Efficient

Gas fireplaces also offer more efficiency and cleaner energy than wood-burning fireplaces. Gas heat emits 99% fewer particulates than wood burning, making gas a good choice for both the planet and your home’s air quality.

The Disadvantages of a Gas Fireplace

1. Needs a Gas Line

A significant drawback for many homeowners, however, is that a gas fireplace requires a gas line. A new gas line can add a considerable extra expense if your home is not already set up for natural gas. Make sure to double-check your gas connection and the cost of connecting your new fireplace before making a decision.

2. Less Authentic Flame

While a gas fireplace does have a real flame, it is still missing some factors of a wood-burning fireplace. With a gas fireplace, you will miss out on the ritual of building a fire, the smell, as well as the gentle crackle. Consider how important these factors are to you and compare them to the convenience gas offers.

Comparing Electric Fireplaces

Electric fireplaces come with sleek style, modern convenience, and futuristic features. While they don’t offer the same nostalgic charm as wood or gas models, electric fireplaces can be the perfect solution for modern homes looking for design within budget. Here are the pros and cons of electric fireplaces.

The Advantages of an Electric Fireplace

1. Inexpensive

Electric fireplaces are the most affordable option when it comes to purchasing, installation, and operation. They require virtually no maintenance and can be connected to any power source in your home.

2. Easy Installation

While wood and gas fireplaces bring concerns about ventilation, gas connections, and construction costs, electric fireplaces can be placed and installed almost anywhere in your home. Electric fireplaces simply require an electric power source, making them an easy addition.

3. Customizable

Electric fireplaces also offer fun options for customization. Since LED lights produce the flames, many models operate similarly to a TV screen allowing for custom flames, colors, and more. While this may not work with the traditional style, it can be a fun feature for a contemporary home.

The Disadvantages of an Electric Fireplace

1. No Alternative Heat Source

One drawback of electric fireplaces is that they don’t offer an alternative heat source. If you are in a cold climate and your electricity goes out, you’re out of luck when it comes to finding other ways of staying warm. However, this is not a concern for warmer climates. It could even prove beneficial for warm climate homes because electric fireplaces can be operated without turning on the heat.

2. Least Authentic Flame

While electric fireplaces have come a long way, and there are many models with convincing flames, they will always lack the authentic feel of a real wood-burning fire. Make sure to assess the value you place on the aesthetics of a real fire before making your choice.

Choosing the Best Fireplace for Your Home

Whether it’s wood-burning, gas, or electric, the fireplace is a focal point of the home that adds a sense of warmth, character, and gathering. Choose the type of fireplace that works best for your home, lifestyle, and budget.

Consider the Fireplace Installation

Take into account how easy it will be to install each type of fireplace into your home. Suppose you are doing a new construction build. In that case, this may be less of a concern because even the most elaborate wood-burning fireplace could be incorporated into the initial house plans. If you’re doing a small remodel, an electric fireplace may be the most straightforward option to add.

Think About Your Lifestyle Needs

With any design decision, consider what is most important to you and fits your lifestyle needs the best. Will you enjoy building a wood-burning fire or find it tiresome? Would you appreciate the ease of a cozy fire at the flip of a switch? Take these factors into account.

Assess Your Fireplace Budget

Finally, assess your allotted budget and see which style fireplace best fits. While you may want to have a gas fireplace incorporated into your remodel, it may prove cost-prohibitive to run a new gas line. Consider the alternatives and outweigh the pros and cons of each fireplace we covered.

Do you need help designing a fireplace for your home?

Tell Us About Your Project

The Pros and Cons of Wood vs. Gas vs. Electric Fireplaces